I can’t remember how many boards I’ve already cut.
I need to build a few house repair kits but then get materials lined up for a reinforced barrier since the day of the zombie raids is just around the corner and the local woman running the tavern needs me to get a vegetable stand rebuilt, and nearby there’s an alley where I can take back some of the town. Ah, that’s right. That’s why I need the barriers. I check my supply chest that I’ve exclusively filled with boards. I open it, peek inside, and then close it, immediately forgetting how many there are because I also see a few scattered red crystals in the corner of the screen. I walk over to collect them and watch my counter tick upwards. Seventy-eight! Okay, that’s enough to unlock the technology to craft a reinforced beam from the circular saw.
Wait, wait, wait. Did I need boards? Or do I need wooden beams? I go back to the supply chest filled with boards. My eyes glaze over the number. I forget how many are in there. Was I just cutting boards to get red experience crystals to unlock the wooden beam tech? No. Wait, yes, but I’ll use these later. Right now I need wooden beams. I’m out of logs. Okay, let’s just go south of the Inquisitor Base… there, logs. Out of stamina and shoot, my insanity is spiking. I slam three bowls of sauerkraut and get sawing. Got the logs, placed them in the storage, and cut out a few beams. Looks like I need to oil the beams and… I have one pot of melted fat left.
I need someone to die so I can liposuction their corpse so I can harvest their fat so I can then melt it down and mix it with two other resources and let it stew and then pull melted fat from the distillation cube to oil this beam so I can retake the sewers so I can unlock faster walking spaces so I can… you’ve gotta be kidding me. You can’t place barriers in the sewers?!

It’s chaos. The signposting is illegible in some places. I stubbornly refuse to pull out a notebook, but boy, I could use one. My brain has melted like butter, and it’s spread too thin across several tech trees and abilities. The precision with which every upgrade path is woven into NPC questlines is immaculately calculated. Nothing’s optional here. You have to do some action to craft some item to appease some person. The systems feed back into each other seamlessly. The whole rigmarole of Graveyard Keeper 2 runs like a darkly humored Rube Goldberg perpetual machine.
Yet here I am, still plugging away, tending graves. Graveyard Keeper 2 carries over some of its predecessor’s best design features to keep the chaos manageable. For example, not tying your stamina to the day/night cycle so you can keep up your workaholic tendencies for a few days on end before insanity overtakes your mental health allows the player to really sink into the dozens of checklist items to do until you’re forced to sleep. And hey, insanity is now a resource, so make good use of that trauma at the writing table.
New to the sequel, each area has supply chests at the ready so your main inventory isn’t overburdened. Crafting stations pull from any supply chest within the area’s range, so it’s much simpler to get to work. But what I desperately wished for was the ability to add resources by item to a blueprint. For some NPC quests, you have this option; you’ll have separate dialogue bubbles per item they require. For regular building or crafting, you have to bring everything at once. In principle, this is just standard gameplay. In a game where automation comes in uneven spurts and you are shuttling bundles of resources across a sizable region, even with fast travel, it becomes tiresome.
However, there’s always a breakthrough moment. After chipping away at several sidequests simultaneously, the dam will break. The subsequent flood of progress is a waterfall of dopamine. Being able to then see the dominoes fall and your hard work pay off resets the grind in a satisfactory way. I tap the left shoulder button and scroll the many, many menus available to me for the thirtieth time in a sixty-minute session.

Venturing deeper into the game, for me, the main draws of Graveyard Keeper 2 became its humor and story. The narrative has some notable intrigue, paralleling the final events of the first game while building out the strange cosmic reality of its medieval setting. I’m reminded of the initial pitch of the first game while still being marketed, and the same charm is present here. While most of the writing and dialogue cue gags and sleight-of-hand trickery, Graveyard Keeper 2 has a metanarrative foundation, poking fun at the errand boy protagonist trope that it wholeheartedly embraces. It’s a self-parody that lands very well.
So despite the game sometimes feeling like hauling a bag of bricks, the bedrock of continually compelling ideas and dark humor kept my interest from waning too long before being pulled back into the merciless woodchipper grind.
Somehow Graveyard Keeper 2 successfully adds a brand new king of the hill combat scenario. When I first saw this in the trailer, I audibly groaned. Adding more to the to-do list would surely overwhelm me. Instead, the combat, though rudimentary, adds a dynamic to the pacing that was sorely missing before. There’s really no complexity here: plant a banner to move your NPC companions to a circle, fight off zombies to take the hill, and find the next area to defend.
All the while the game is a wonder to watch in action. The animations, sound design, softly detailed sprites and assets all suggest a rolling serenity while steadily working through its many systems. It’s easy to get lost in the work, which is maybe why every townsperson will volunteer for you to do their duties. The pixel art delights with meticulous shading and noticeable shimmers on the water and an extra touch in detail across the map.

As the mystery really begins to come into focus some fifteen, maybe twenty hours into the game, the path towards the end is a steep but straight uphill climb. From here on out the rhythms have been well established, and my zombie workers are better organized. The grind is still wildly exaggerated, but since I’m zeroed into the game’s mechanics, I’m much more at peace with how the game works, and I continue digging graves while my spouse watches a movie.
In a game that features resurrection as a prominent mechanic and theme, Graveyard Keeper 2 makes me consider more thoroughly what sequels should accomplish. Defining style as a set of shared characteristics across the output of an artist, it can be difficult or impossible to measure expectations from one game to its direct sequel because the sample size for measuring style is small.
Since Lazy Bear’s release of Graveyard Keeper in 2018, nearly a decade ago, they’ve been busy making great games, but there’s something endearingly theirs in this off-beat medieval world they’ve continued in the sequel. Graveyard Keeper 2 is not without its frustrations, and I imagine most players would rub their temples raw at the roundabout ways required of them to craft key items. But they’ve stuck a gold vein, tucked in between the many layers of routine management sim games that will resonate for the niche player who enjoys medieval settings doused in unsettling humor.
Verdict
Graveyard Keeper 2 would be considered a bloat-filled management sim if it didn’t so smartly entangle all of its systems. The grind will frustrate many with its long trail of dominoes, but once the first one falls, it never stops delighting. Highly recommended for a specific audience of players who appreciate dark humor, detailed pixel art, and slowly trickled storytelling.
- Release Date
- 22nd September 2026
- Platforms
- PC, Nintendo Switch, Nintendo Switch 2, PS5, XBOX Series S/X, XBOX One
- Developer
- Lazy Bear Games
- Publisher
- tinyBuild
- Accessibility
- None
- Version Tested
- Nintendo Switch 2
Many thanks to the publisher for the review copy.
About the Author
Jacob Price
About the Author
Jacob Price
Jacob Price, aka The Pixel Professor, is an indie superfan. Having played games his whole life, he studies and teaches the literary merit of games as a university instructor. You can find him on Bluesky here and listen to him and his co-host Cameron Warren on the Pre-Order Bonus Podcast, as well as catch him live part-time on Twitch.