Curse of Resthaven

As a fan of Lil’ Guardsman (2024), I have been eagerly anticipating Hilltop Studios’ second title, The Curse of Resthaven. You play as Ambrose, a well-to-do young man who has volunteered to govern a backwater island colony with the aim of finding his missing niece, Amalia. You quickly encounter various other mysteries, such as the suspicious circumstances under which your predecessor met his untimely end. The former governor left the colony in a state of destitution and disrepair. Even if you aren’t interested in helping the locals, you’re going to need to improve the local economy to progress the main story. But I suspect most players will be moved by the plight of the townsfolk and eager to solve their various problems.

Resthaven boasts a diverse cast of characters that manage to avoid well-worn archetypes or tropes. There were some genuinely surprising turns of events. I also wanted to chat with them about non-path-critical matters to hear their different views about issues such as colonization, religion, war, and empirical science. Resthaven and the Aurelian Empire are entirely fictional, but based on the 18th and 19th centuries, and I found a lot of real-world resonances in its meditation on the foregoing themes.

Resthaven is an unusual genre mash-up of adventure, detective, town management, and card game. The adventure-game components look and play similarly to games like Pentiment. You move Ambrose through 2D environments with parallax effects either by using WASD or double clicking your intended destination. There are only so many actions Ambrose can perform in a day, so you need to strategize how best to use your time. One of the main things you’re doing is questioning townsfolk, during which you ask a limited number of questions from a list of topics you’ve already discovered.

Another part of Ambrose’s day is collecting taxes from local businesses in the form of resource cards (e.g., bread, lumber, shields, jewellery, and arcane objects). Ambrose uses those cards to trade with merchant ships. The relative worth of each item depends not only on global changes in the stock of certain item types but also on the needs of the nations the merchants serve. Ambrose sets the prices, but if he charges too much for his wares or makes too low a bid on items for sale, the merchant may walk away.

Amalia is lost in the surrounding wilderness, so Ambrose will also need to undertake expeditions to discover clues as to her whereabouts. Completing expeditions also establishes outposts, which are necessary to unlocking later vendor upgrades. Expeditions are also represented by playing cards, which initially only contain a hint as to the type of items or personnel required to successfully complete the task. A local seer can reveal the precise conditions for success, but at a price that escalates the further you are in your playthrough. While I did guess a few times, these attempts were generally unsuccessful. Even if you have nearly every resource card in your hand, you can’t bring your entire hand on the expedition. And playing the wrong card not only means wasting valuable in-game time but also losing the cards you brought along.

Detective game UI design is an undeniable challenge, but there is a lot to admire in Hilltop’s choices. I began taking notes but quickly realized that the game was keeping track not only of important leads but also of the time and place of notable story events. There is fast travel to key locations, and you can even jump forward to any time in the future. My only wish was that there was a faster way of collecting resource cards from vendors.

Resthaven has a striking and varied visual style. There is a (somewhat awkward) walking animation for Ambrose, but conversations are represented by static character portraits. Even before a character says anything, their profession and personality are clear from their portrait. I would, however, have appreciated portraits changing with characters’ emotions. Even Ambrose only has a single portrait. The grotesque and horrific scenes Ambrose encounters on expeditions are represented by static black and white drawings reminiscent of Slay the Princess. Leaving components to the imagination contributed to the horror, though some images in these sections felt a bit like concept art.

Studio director Scott Christian’s background in music, specifically musical theatre, was on ample display in Hilltop’s debut title Lil’ Guardsman. The bleak and twisted nature of The Curse of Resthaven didn’t afford Christian as many opportunities for either his musical or comedic gifts apart from songs sung by a bard at a local tavern and a Punch and Judy-style puppet show. Remarkably for the game’s size and scope, Resthaven contains full voice acting by a diverse and highly acclaimed cast of Canadian actors for the stage and screen.

After 6 days, a cataclysm occurs, and Ambrose finds himself newly arrived on the island again. Surprise: The Curse of Resthaven is a roguelite! It’s impossible to solve the main story or even most of the side stories in a single loop. Thankfully, Ambrose’s knowledge of his various investigations carries over, as do vendor upgrades, relationships with merchants, and boons you acquire at the end of loops.

During my first few play sessions, I was hanging on characters’ every word. I was following many leads. Every action point seemed to count. Half a dozen hours later, I had fully upgraded all vendors and solved some side quests, but the main quest was bottlenecked. I hadn’t prioritized expeditions enough early on, and the game only allows you to complete one per in-game day. Around 10 hours in, I got to an ending, but I’d still not wrapped up Amalia’s story. The game asked me whether I wanted to start another playthrough, and my heart sank. I wanted to learn more about Amalia, and I was curious how subsequent playthroughs would differ, so I kept going.

When you begin a new playthrough, you lose most of your progress, though Hilltop did introduce some measures to make replaying the game less tedious. The boons you earned in your first playthrough carry over. There is also a déjà-vu-type mechanic by which Ambrose will remember certain aspects of quests and allow you to send your butler to take care of them while you pursue other leads. Additionally, fewer expeditions are required to advance Amalia’s story. Even so, I found my second playthrough so repetitive that I abandoned it. I found myself skipping most of the dialogue. As I neared my second ending, I started to see more differences, but there wasn’t enough new material to keep me going. I ran into a roadblock and took that as an excuse to bow out.

The story-driven roguelite may be another cursed design problem. There is a reason most roguelites are either action games or deck builders. For people who enjoy killing monsters, playing through the same biomes and bosses in Hades is rewarding in and of itself. As long as the combat is deep and varied, fans of the core gameplay loop can remain engaged for dozens of hours. I speak from experience.

When I was uncovering new facets of the story, playing The Curse of Resthaven was like immersing myself in a great gothic adventure. And the card-based resource management elements kept my gamer brain engaged. I stayed up rather too late several days in a row so that I could reach this or that milestone either in the town or in my investigations. The problem is the caveat “when I was uncovering new facets of the story.” Resthaven’s card-based mechanics aren’t deep enough to sustain hours of play on their own. It is, as Hilltop Studios knows, a story-driven game. Music may be the art of repetition, but storytelling is not. No matter how good the writing is, I don’t want to listen to the same dialogue over and over. Roguelites involve repetition, but story-focused games require the story to progress. These components pull in opposite directions. The problem is cursed.

And yet, I have played several successful narrative-focused timeloop games this year, such as Until Then (2024), Slay the Princess (2023), and Expelled! (2025). How did these developers do it? In Until Then, new things started happening right away. Small changes kept me going until bigger and bigger differences appeared that saw me through to its “true ending.” Slay the Princess and Expelled!, by contrast, were highly branching stories that had me constantly asking questions like, “I wonder what happens if I do …,” often leading to Jon Ingold’s gold standard: “Yikes, what have I done?” Expelled! also had a brilliant system for letting me know what dialogue I’ve seen and allowing me to fast-forward through it to the new content.

In Resthaven, there are choices about which side quests to pursue, but the main path of any playthrough is linear. This is a fine choice in isolation, of course, but not one that paired well with its roguelite structure. Another thing both Slay the Princess and Expelled! had on their side was their much smaller scope and duration. If I could have felt closure with respect to Resthaven’s main story beats under 10 hours, ideally even fewer, I suspect my score would have been substantially higher. But more content is better, right? Not for me. I’d rather roll credits, still being in love with the game, than feel glad that I can move on to something else.

For a small team to have another game launching just 2 years after their first is impressive. However, I wish Hilltop Studios had been able to take more time for player testing, not just of the core gameplay loop for new players, but also to discern whether what they had produced could support the number of hours they were hoping players would spend with their game.

Verdict

3.5/5

The Curse of Resthaven has the vibes of Dredge but the looping structure of Slay the Princes or Expelled! Most of my first playthrough was utterly engrossing, but diminishing returns led me to abandon my second playthrough prior to its conclusion. Sadly, Resthaven fails to solve the curse of the narrative roguelite and could have benefitted from some design tips from Inkle.

Release Date
27th October 2026
Platforms
PC, PS5, XBOX Series S/X
Developer
Hilltop Studios
Publisher
Digital Bandidos
Accessibility
None
Version Tested
PC (Steam)

Many thanks to the publisher for the review copy.